Let's Connect:

real talk + attainable fashion


All Time Favorite Amazon Fashion Items

June 16, 2021


Erin Schrader

If you would have asked us 5 years ago how many items in our closets were from Amazon, we’d probably tell ya a big fat goose egg [aka zero]. And now here we are in 2021 having a hard time picking our absolute favorites! Yes, that’s right, we have that many Amazon fashion items we’ve loved that we’re having a hard time narrowing down our top picks! But we like to do hard things 😉 So here you have it, our highly condensed, all-time favorite Amazon fashion items, from our Prime account to yours!

Erin’s Amazon Fashion Favorites

One Piece Swimsuit

Hilor One Piece Swimsuit [true to size, wearing in small in rose red]

I was so pleasantly surprised when I put this swimsuit on for the first time – for the price, I wasn’t convinced it was going to be anything worth talking about but I was wrong. I love how flattering this suit is thanks to the mesh detail, wide straps, full booty coverage and supportive chest area! I know I’ll be wearing this beauty regularly this summer!

Halter Neck Ruffle Dress

BTFBM Halter Neck Ruffle Dress [true to size, wearing in small in polka dot red] 

The minute I slipped this dress on I knew it was going to be an instant favorite. I am a sucker for a halter neckline and this cutie is no exception. It’s flirty, it’s fun, [and it’s lined which makes this mid-30 something happy ;)]] 

Strapless Maxi Dress

Yidarton Strapless Maxi Dress [true to size, wearing in small in flower red green] 

Speaking of all-time favorite dresses at Amazon, this maxi is ranking HIGH on the list. I bought it after seeing Claire on the team looking adorable in it and I’ve already gone back for more colors since. It’s easy, it’s breezy, it works for events, and the best part – you can go sans bra thanks to the layered chest area making that our little secret. 

Sleeveless VNeck Sweater

Sleeveless V-Neck Sweater [size down if in between, wearing in small in sky blue and brown] 

I never knew I could love a sleeveless sweater as much as this, but ever since it’s arrived I haven’t stopped wearing it. I’ve now taken it on two dates with me and both times it got a compliment out of my husband – that my friends, is a winning top!

Anrabess Turtleneck Sweater

Anrabess Turtleneck Sweater

It’s a sweater I’ve bought over [and over and yes, over] again. When you find something you love, buy it in every color, right? This has been a go-to for fall and winter for over a year now and I have no intentions of stopping wearing it anytime soon. I love the fit [it is slightly oversized so size down if in between] and think the material is great! You can wear it with jeans or leggings which automatically earns some brownie points with me. Best Amazon sweater I’ve purchased to date!

Core 10 Build Your Own Onstride Leggings

Core 10 Build Your Own Onstride Leggings

The leggings that stuck with me through a million and two quarantine walks and beyond. These won our “best of athletic leggings” comparison months ago and I haven’t doubted that claim since. I love the mesh ventilation on the back of the knee, a fun zipper detail at the ankle, and a ton of hidden pockets for your keys/money while out and about or at the gym. They’re the BYO [build your own] style, so you can pick your rise and your inseam to fit how you prefer! They are so comfortable and have stayed in perfect shape wash after wash! I find them true to size!

Steph’s Fashion Favs

Leopard Cardigan Coat

Leopard Print Cardigan Coat [Size down, wearing in Small in A-Beige]

Can’t stop, won’t stop with this sweater. I received it last Fall and I’ve worn it an embarrassing amount of times since then. It’s thick and warm, layers beautifully and has pockets (which I recently started using to keep my mask in when between errands). I love it so much, I just might marry it.

Hannah’s Amazon Fashion Favorites

Sports Bras

Racerback Sports Bras [TTS]

Hands down the most comfortable sports bras I have ever owned!! Their over 20,000 reviews sold me but after slipping them on and working out in them, I could wear them ALL day they are that comfortable! Easy to slip on and off [post workout] and the band doesn’t dig into you! If you are in need of a new sports bra, I highly recommend you give these a try!

Puffer Coat

Amazon Essentials Mid Weight Long Puffer Coat [TTS, wearing in XS]

This Amazon coat surprised me! Despite my petite frame it’s not too long and a medium weight without being bulky! Also, the pockets are sherpa lined AND there’s an interior zipper pocket!

One Piece Swimsuit

Cupshe Lace One Piece Swimsuit [TTS]

This NEW to me one piece is by far my new favorite swimsuit!! Despite the moderate bum coverage I didn’t feel too exposed and felt so confident and comfortable in this one!! Just the right amount of details to make this one great quality and a keeper!

CRZ Yoga Leggings

CRZ Yoga Leggings [Size down if in between] / CRZ Yoga Sports Bra [TTS]

The most comfortable leggings for working out or lounging in!! These buttery soft leopard leggings are so comfortable, crazy soft and moisture wicking! Pair it with this cute strappy sports bra and your workout wear just got a new look!

Claire’s Amazon Fashion Favorites

Tie Dye Lounge Set

Tie-Dye Lounge Set: Top [TTS, wearing medium in Wheat] // Shorts [TTS, wearing medium in Wheat]

Meet the cute little tie-dye set I can’t stop [will not stop] wearing. So soft and comfy, you better believe I’ll be ordering another color! True to size, but size down if in between. This is my regular size medium with plenty of wiggle room.

Long Puffer Coat

Amazon Essentials Mid Weight Long Puffer Coat 

This coat was a pleasant surprise and I ended up wearing it a TON this winter! It is so warm [like, sweating during a Midwest winter] and available in several color options. Size down if in between! 

Pull On Shorts

Pull-On Drawstring Shorts 

Ladies, do yourself a favor and get a pair [or three, who’s counting? 😉 ] of pull-on shorts this summer! They’re super comfy – without sacrificing style – plus nice and lightweight for hot days! Available in 23 [yes, 2-3!] color options!


Striped Cardigan [TTS, wearing medium] 

Feeling like a scoop of neapolitan ice cream and I’m not mad about it. 😉 If you’re in need of a great cardi, this one is available in a ton of color combinations! True to size, wearing in medium. 


Jumpsuit [TTS, size up if in between] 

I’m a firm believer that a classic black jumpsuit should be a staple in every woman’s closet. This one is super stretchy and available in several colors. Dress it up or dress it down, the world is your oyster! I’m wearing this in my normal size medium, but would suggest sizing up if in between sizes! 

Joggers & Tank

Joggers on left [size up if in between, wearing medium] // Joggers on right [TTS, wearing medium] // Tank [TTS, with built-in bra!]

If you’re a fan of the Athleta Trekkie or Lululemon Dance Studio joggers, these are going to right up your alley! You better believe these Amazon finds are getting a TON of love already. Such similar quality, I highly recommend!

Cassidy’s Amazon Fashion Favorites


Seersucker Cover Up [wearing in size small] // Orange and Blue Suit [wearing in size small] I am typically a size 2-4 and am 5’4! 

Yup. I found my perfect suit! I am IN LOVE with this suit from Cupshe! I love the blues and oranges together [hello complimentary colors] and it fits like a glove! The belt is adjustable and can be removed if you desire but I personally love the detail that it adds to the suit! The gold detailing was also a huge win for me–I feel like it makes the suit look more expensive than it is! It is slightly cheeky, buuuuuut I also have a big booty so…. Maybe on others it wouldn’t be too bad! But for me, I was comfortable in it and would have no issues wearing it around the pool or at the beach! The overall fit was really comfy and pretty much is the same shape as all the other suits I own [I love the high waist for my pear shaped body]! I paired it with this simple but chic cover up that I also fell in love with! It is a seersucker material, lightweight, and sheer but not see through! It does fit a little boxy when it’s all buttoned up, but I love wearing it open as well to show off our cute suits!


Sweater [Wearing in size XS]

I have been wearing this cropped sweater on repeat! I love wearing it on it’s own but it also looks adorable open with a tank or tee underneath! I usually don’t wear much red but something about this lil baby caught my eye and I had to have it! I am really loving the fun it brings to my closet!

Lauren’s Amazon Fashion Favorites

Birk Lookalikes

Cushionaire Sandals  [size up .5, color is Taupe] 

I’ve been wearing these Birkenstock lookalike sandals for a bit now, and OH BABY they are good! SUPER comfortable and the price is right [under $25!]. I did size up .5 size and am glad I did! I wore them for a few days just around the house to sort of break them in! They have plenty of support, and so far I’m loving them! If I haven’t convinced you, let the 23,000+ reviews 😉 


2-Pack Sunglasses

2 for the price of 1? That’s my kind of sunglasses purchase, because you better believe I’m going to lose or scratch one in no time! Several color combinations and a classic aviator style, you just can’t go wrong!


6-Pack Thongs

With almost 30,000 positive reviews, I had to try these thongs  [c’mon, under $10 for a 6-pack?!]. Well, I can now say see ya later Victoria’s Secret! No more paying $10 per panty! They’re a cotton material, breathable fabric, and overall just a great set! Really, there are no frills to these, which is what I needed for everyday underwear!

Duster Cardigan

Duster Cardigan [size down, wearing in small] // Tank top [TTS, wearing in medium] // Denim [TTS] //  Wedge Sneakers [size up .5] 

My cardigan rule? The longer the better. So this duster cardigan [aka basically floor length] is my jam! The perfect extra layer for working from home or running around town! Size down! Wearing in small!

Swimsuit Coverup

Harhay Swimsuit Coverup [color is 01 Beige] // Similar Bag 

I fell in love with this crochet coverup almost two years ago, and it’s still one of my absolute favorites! I’ve worn it everywhere from local lakes to the beaches of the Bahamas, and it’s held up surprisingly well!

Rattan Headband

Rattan Headband // Shirt

A little rattan goes a long way! This cute Amazon headband is part of a 4-pack, and perfect to add on to your daily look or to rock beach or poolside!

Buttery Soft Leggings

Colorfulkoala Leggings Printed // Colorfulkoala Leggings Solids

These leggings have been worn on repeat [literally weekly or several times a week] for the past year! AND they worked for the first 6ish months of pregnancy! They’ve been called out as being a dupe for the Lululemon Align leggings, and I’d have to agree with that! True to size, available in plenty of colors and prints!

Katy’s Amazon Fashion Favorites

Midi Skirt

Midi Skirt [size down if in between, wearing XS] // Levi’s Tee [size up if in between, wearing XS] // Sandals [size up .5] 

I love when a piece helps me feel put together but is also COMFORTABLE. This skirt does it all! Feels like a tee, but elevates a look!

Oversized Denim Jacket

Oversized Denim Jacket [size down if in between, wearing XS] // Tee [size up one] // Jeans [true to size] // Sneakers [true to size]

This jacket is giving me 90’s vibes & I’m here for it It’s definitely for an oversized look, so if you’re not into that sort of thing I would size down at least one. I throw this one on over every type of look!

Teddy Coat

Teddy Coat [true to size, wearing XS] // Left Jeans [size down if in between] // Right Jeans [true to size] // Beanie // Similar Left Boots // Right Boots [size down .5]

This coat has been a staple for me this past year! It is such great quality and is perfect to throw on to dress up a look or just to run errands! 

LIY Ambassador Amazon Fashion Favorites

Lisa’s Earrings


These comfortable rose gold hoops are a staple in my jewelry box. The clasp back is so comfortable and they easily dress up a casual outfit.  No tarnishing or wearing either and wear them several times a week!

share this with your best girlfriends:

Read More

Sweater weather is upon us, with cool, crisp, mornings to kick off afternoons at the pumpkin patch! *insert happy dance* Whether you’re looking for cozy cardigans, comfy cowl necks, or show a little skin with off-the-shoulder numbers, we’re sharing the 20 Best Sweaters for Fall! Before we get into all of the outfits, let’s get […]

Read More

Shackets [aka shirt-jackets] are taking over the internet… as well as the LIY team’s closets.

Read More

Come in and cozy up, the cabin fall tour is ready for you!

Read More

Crockin’ and rockin’ – that’s how we roll. As soon as those temps start to dip in the mornings and evenings, you can find us puling out the ol’ crockpot and our favorite fall recipes. There’s nothing better than coming home from a day at the office to the smell of the food that’s been […]

Oldies but Goodies

Check Out These

The newsletter you actually want to read.

signed, sealed, delivered.

© Living in Yellow. Site Credits.