Let's Connect:

real talk + attainable fashion


LIY Tested + Approved: Bath Towel Edition

December 16, 2020


Erin Schrader

Here at LIY, we take our job of answering life’s biggest questions pretty seriously. You know, questions like “What are the best bath towels?”– it’s a tough job but somebody’s gotta do it. It’s a question we’ve received frequently over the years and quite honestly, don’t have the answer to. Until now. Never fear, Team LIY is here and taking matters into our own hands [errr, bathrooms]. We rounded up seven popular towel brands and put them to the ultimate test [ie. used ’em and reviewed ’em]. The wait is finally over! Allow me to introduce the best bath towels on the market– according to yours truly. Drumroll please…

ps. You can check out all of our product comparison posts here!

How We Tested

Before we dive in, here’s the lowdown on the testing process. It was simple, really. A few ladies from the LIY team volunteered to take each brand of towel for a whirl [don’t worry, we each got our own 😉 ], noting important features like thickness, texture, absorbency, how well they held up in the wash and if they shed an annoying amount of fuzzies. These are our results!

The Lineup:

Our Top Picks

  • Nordstrom Hydrocotton Bath Towel: My love for Nordstrom runs deep, so it’s no surprise that their bath towels [with 600+ positive reviews] did not disappoint. They’re super soft, thick, fluffy, and absorbent– checking all the boxes. While they are slightly on the “spend” side compared to several other towels tested, you can tell from the touch that they’re high quality and well made.
  • Pottery Barn Classic Organic Towels: Pottery Barn was another brand that ranked highly in our ratings. Again, no surprise here. While it wasn’t necessarily the softest of the towels tested, it was the thickest, washed up well, and didn’t leave fuzzies behind. When it comes to the price point, it’s very comparable to Nordstrom Brand, and once again, you’ll probably get what you pay for long-term! We likey.
  • Martha Stewart for Macy’s Spa Bath Towel [on sale with code GIVE]:  Martha, you’ve got it going on. And talk about bang for your buck! At full price, this brand is about $10 cheaper than Nordstrom and Pottery Barn, but if you did a blind test, you probably wouldn’t notice a huge difference. Who says you can’t stick to a budget without sacrificing quality? Us [and Martha Stewart], that’s who. ps. It’s currently on sale for $10 with code GIVE! So go ahead and give yourself the gift of new towels.

Best Budget-Friendly Options

  • AmazonBasics: Amazon for the win! If you’re familiar with the AmazonBasics brand, then chances are, you might already know how good it is. From bath towels to phone charges, their products are typically reliable and budget friendly. These towels come as a set of two, putting them around ten bucks a pop. They were VERY similar to some of the higher end brands we tested [but not quite as thick], for a fraction of the price. They’re soft, fluffy, and washed well. If you’re looking to save a few pennies [who isn’t?] or need ’em in a jiffy [shoutout Prime!], we’re giving these a thumbs up!
  • Casaluna Organic Bath Towel: Here’s the deal. After washing and drying all the towels, lining them up next to each other, and conducting a blind test [AKA feeling them up]; we couldn’t tell much of a difference between the $10 Target Brand and the $30 Nordstrom and Pottery Barn brands. I can’t speak to how well they’ll hold up long term, but so far, so good. After a few uses and washes, I’m a fan. If I were in need of a new set of towels, you better believe I’m saving the extra $20 and going for the Targ brand.

Honorable Mention

  • Norwex Microfiber Bath Towel: This was an unexpected win for several of us! While it’s not your standard thick and fluffy towel, it was by-far most absorbent. This is a thin, microfiber towel– so we were at bit skeptical at first. If you’re picky about the texture of fabric on your skin, this might not be the one for you. It was also the most expensive of the towels we tested, so didn’t necessarily steal our hearts for the price. If you’re curious and willing to try something new [and have an extra $50 laying around 😉 ], we don’t think you’ll be disappointed. Bonus: it has a fun loop sewn in for hanging!

Don’t Waste Your Money

  • Utopia Towels Premium Bath Towels [Set of 4]: Ladies and gents, allow me to introduce our least favorite overall. Do yourself a favor and don’t waste your dollars. This one had 3,300+ positive reviews on Amazon, so we had high expectations. Unfortunately, it was the roughest, least soft/fluffy, and was fraying after one wash. In hindsight, this was the cheapest set we tested [$32 for a 4-pack], so we got what we paid for. Throw in the towel on that one.

Brands We Tested:

share this with your best girlfriends:

  1. Shaila says:

    Norwex towels ❤️ These towels have BacLock in the microfiber to help prevent the stink of the towel. It is kinda like a self-cleaning mode. I seriously wash my Norwex towel once every 2 weeks. Saves me money snd time doing loads of towels. ????????

  2. TH says:

    I bought a whole new set of the Nordstrom Hydrocotton last year. They are indeed very fluffy and good quality. The problem is in the color. I wish I could post a photo here to show how the color has changed–after just a few months. My beige oatmeal (which had grey undertones) is completely yellow now.

  3. Valentina says:

    Great idea to review these towels. Which brand comes in the bright yellow?

Read More

It’s no secret around these parts that we have a seriously love affair with Liverpool Los Angeles items. From the stretchiest jackets to the best work pants to the jeans that hug you in all the right places, they truly can do no wrong. And their Fall lineup isn’t messing around either – it is […]

Read More

Another month, another round of Amazon items we couldn’t say no to! Home decor? Yep. Fashion? Yep that too. Beauty? Mmmhmm! Keep on scrolling to see what the LIY Team and LIY Ambassadors are loving this month from Amazon! Erin’s Amazon Finds Erin’s Samsung Frame TV Magnetic Bezel The Frame TV Magnetic Bezel // Downloadable […]

Read More

Here at LIY, we believe cheap wine doesn’t have to taste like cheap wine [not that we would know the difference, since we only ever drink cheap wine]. When it comes to grocery store wines, we know firsthand how overwhelming the options can be. The shelves are stocked with endless options, most of which we’ve […]

Read More

With wrapping up Breast Cancer Awareness Month today, women’s health is top of mind here at LIY. Luckily we know someone who is super knowledgeable on the subject. We recently asked our girlfriend — Steph Brenneman, FNP-BC — about all things lady lumps, and we thought we would share with you! Before we begin, just […]

Oldies but Goodies

Check Out These

Let's make this relationship official.

signed, sealed, delivered.

© Living in Yellow. Site Credits.