20+ Amazon Items We Order On Repeat

Apr

By:

Team LIY

22

2026

Repeat offenders, we’ll admit it! When we find something we love, we’re going to order it again and again [and again]. We’re sharing the items that Amazon is asking us if we want to “buy it again” that we say yes to each and every time! From beauty and fashion finds to home and more, these are the items we’re buying on repeat!

Beauty

Medicube Collagen Jelly Cream

This collagen jelly cream has been the #1 best-selling beauty item with the LIY Community two years in a row– and for good reason, I just applied it last night and this morning I woke up and thought “wow, my skin feels tight and smooth.” It’s a miracle worker and it’s only $15 [and rated excellent on the YUKA app]!

Pureology Color Fanatic

Who else swears by this stuff?! I’ve been using it for years [I spray it in wet hair before I blow dry]! Great detangler + heat protectant + 19 other benefits!

Medicube PDRN Collagen Sheet Mask

The mask I made the entire LIY Team try because I love it so much! Between it’s incredible glow after use and cooling sensation during, this mask is a game-changer! I’ve never been more impressed with the results from a mask!

Divi Scalp Serum

The scalp serum that saved my hair! It’s helped so much with regrowth of my hair and feels so good when applying!

Paula’s Choice SKIN PERFECTING 2% BHA Liquid Exfoliant with Salicylic Acid

Jen here and it’s fair to say that when I turned 40 my skin decided to go completely out of whack! This has been the only thing to keep it balanced and in line! Truly – I never go without.. if I do… back to whack my skin goes! After I cleanse I tone with this, then follow with serum and moisturizer! I only use it in the PM.

Pacifica Glow Baby

Devon here! I have been using this vitamin C serum for years. It’s a clean product for a very reasonable price and I absolutely LOVE it. It gives me an instant dewy glow and smells AHH–MAZING!

Home

Coop Adjustable Pillow

Every single night when we lay our heads on this pillow we’re reminded of exactly why it won our pillow comparison! It truly is the best! We love that it’s adjustable and that you can add or remove stuffing to make it as firm [or not firm] as you need. It won our pillow comparison for side, back, and mixed sleepers!

Nespresso Capsules Vertuo, Golden Caramel, Medium Roast Coffee

Do we have a favorite Nespresso pod flavor you ask…. I guess this answers that! Golden Caramel is our go-to around here at the Marrs Home and our guests are always wondering “what flavor that was” when they take their first sip too! So I guess that says something… she’ll be sticking around!

Bed Sheets

Yes, one of us has bought these sheets 4 times, but throughout the whole LIY team we’ve probably bought them 15+ times! They hold up well wash after wash, don’t wrinkle, and come in a ton of colors + prints at a great price point! Over 375,000+ reviews!

Fashion

Athletic Shorts [true to size, Erin wears in Medium]

You’re reading that right – purchased 20 times! While other athletic shorts exist, it’s hard to beat the Amazon athletic shorts that we all love so much! The build in underwear liner, the zipper pocket, the thick high waist band, the color options, and last but not least – the price!

Under $15 Sunglasses

Forget the pricey pairs, the only sunglasses I wear are these classics from Amazon that are almost always under $15!

Misc.

LMNT Zero Sugar Electrolytes

Whether it’s after the sauna, a workout, or a day I am just feeling dehydrated these LMNT electrolyte packs are a must! Plus, we can feel good about them having zero sugar! We like to add them to a 40oz cup and sip ’em all day!

Armra Colostrum Immune Revival

Erin loves the Armra Colostrum! A few things she’s noticed… 1] Better bowel movements [less bloat thanks to regularity]! 2] Resilience levels on my Oura ring have moved up TWICE in the last two weeks [they had never moved up since wearing it until starting Armra. 3] More water consumption to start my day which is always a win/win!

Stur Liquid Water Enhancer

Miss Mouth’s Messy Eater Stain Treater

NaturVet Arthrisoothe Glucosamine for Dogs

Meet Minnie Marrs… going on 14 years old! These have been her saving grace when it comes to getting around the house, up and down stairs – jumping up on the bed and the couch 😉 … she’s our princess! She gets 6 of these nightly and I have to say they have worked wonders with her joints allowing her to walk, jump, live with ease! We now have these on auto-ship because I will not allow her to go one night without… again, she’s our girl [our only girl] 🙂

Mary Ruth’s Liquid Multivitamins

The only vitamins my family takes! I swear this stuff is like liquid gold and the one and only item I subscribe and save to!

Amazon Essentials Hand Soap Refill

Random but essential for our household [haha]. We go through a lot of hand soap and this just does the job and I can quickly order it and never run out or forget to buy it at the grocery store.

Harney & Sons Hot Cinnamon Tea

If you’ve never tried this tea, it’s a staple in our home! My entire family drinks this stuff, especially in the colder months. Erin introduced this to us and we’ve been buying it ever since!

Molly’s Suds Laundry Detergent

Share this with your best girlfriends

Work With Us

hello@livinginyellow.com

Want to say hello? Let’s chat! There’s nothing that makes us happier than a little love note in our inbox. Drop us a line at the email below, or fill out our Contact Form! 

Your information

Your Message

Thank you for your note! We look forward to being in touch with you soon.

Since 2011

Since 2011, Living in Yellow brings the fun to fashion and everyday life.

Our mission is to be a positive light to our community and connect with women both online and in-person. We create and share resources, products, and experiences that help them live a more confident, convenient, and joyful lifestyle.