Let's Connect:


daily looks

LIY Tribe Fashion Favorites Results

December 30, 2017


Erin Schrader

The people [you!] have spoken! A few weeks ago we put out a survey asking YOU, the LIY Tribe, to tell us of your favorites in all things fashion! You may recall a couple of months ago when we did the same thing with beauty products and had so much fun with it, we wanted to do it with the things we talk about the most – clothes, shoes and accessories! From casual to loungewear to workwear and more, this post tackles over 50 categories and below you’ll see the final top three results in each! The goal of this post is to point you in the direction of some top rated products from women just like you! Real-life humans of all shapes and sizes who collectively agree that this, that or the other is truly awesome and worth purchasing! There’s no better time than the new year to stock up on some great quality pieces to last you all year long [plus, I mean..sales and gift cards, amen?] Because this post is plenty long, we’ll go ahead and jump in! All links and size tips are listed below! Have fun and hey – thanks for your input, we sure do love you for it!

Tops & OuterwearBasic Tank/Cami

  1. Old Navy Luxe High-Neck Swing Tank [25.5%] Size down if in between! 
  2. Old Navy Brushed Tank [19.4%] Size down if in between! 
  3. Madewell Whisper Cotton V-Neck Tank [11.3%] True to size! 

Basic Tee 

  1. Madewell Whisper Cotton V-Neck Tee [14.3%] Size down! 
  2. Mossimo Relaxed V-Neck Tee [11.2%] True to size! 
  3. American Eagle Soft & Sexy V-Neck Tee [10.8%] True to size! 

Basic Long Sleeve

  1. Caslon Long Sleeve Crewneck Tee [15.3%] True to size! 
  2. Old Navy Relaxed Plush Knit Tee [13.3%] Size down if in between! 
  3. American Eagle Soft & Sexy Favorite Long Sleeve Tee [12%] True to size! 

Casual Top

  1. American Eagle Ahh-mayzingly Soft Plaid Boyfriend Shirt [19.3%] Size up! 
  2. BP V-Neck Pullover [8.9%] True to size! 
  3. Lush Henley [8.7%] True to size! 

Going Out Top

  1. Lush Perfect Roll Tab Sleeve Tunic [39.4%] Size down! 
  2. Gibson Cold Shoulder Top [13.9%] Size down! 
  3. Halogen Lace & Crepe Top [12.6%] True to size! 

Casual Dress

  1. Leith Ruched Body Con Tank Dress [18.9%] Size up for more comfortable fit! 
  2. Old Navy Sleeveless Cutout Back Shift Dress [17.5%] True to size!
  3. Abercrombie & Fitch Cozy Swing Dress [13.2%] True to size!

Going Out Dress

  1. Charles Henry Off The Shoulder Dress [20.1%] Size down! 
  2. Leith Ruched Body Con Tank Dress [17.4%] Size up for a more comfortable fit! 
  3. Lush Hailey Crepe Dress [14%] True to size!


  1. BP V-Neck Long Sleeve Sweater [28.1%] Size down! 
  2. Lou & Grey Boucle Cowl Sweater [9.6%] True to size! 
  3. BP V-Neck Sweater [9.4%] True to size!


  1. Barefoot Dreams Cozy Chic Circle Cardigan [28.3%] True to size!
  2. Old Navy Open Front Long Line Sweater [17.3%] True to size!
  3. Halogen Long Open Front Cardigan [11.6%] Size down if in between! 


  1. Patagonia Snap T Quilted Pullover [18.3%] True to size!
  2. Zella Frosty Asymmetrical Zip Pullover [13.7%] Size up! 
  3. Zella Outta Town Hoodie [13%] Size up! 

Cozy Top

  1. Barefoot Dreams Cozy Pullover [42%] True to size!
  2. Make & Model Cozy Crew Raglan Sweatshirt [16.3%] True to size!
  3. Make & Model Gotta Have It Tee [13%] Size down if in between! 


  1. Old Navy Quilted Vest [29.7%] True to size!
  2. Old Navy Frost Free Vest [26.6%] True to size!
  3. Patagonia Bivy Hooded Down Vest [14.2%] True to size!


  1. Old Navy Twill Field Jacket [25.6%] True to size!
  2. Loft Frayed Military Jacket [13.2%] True to size!
  3. Kut From The Kloth Helena Denim Jacket [10.7%] Size up if in between! 


  1. American Eagle Faux Fur Hooded Parka [17.8%] Size down! 
  2. 32 Degrees Packable Down Puffer Jacket [11.2%] True to size!
  3. Abercrombie and Fitch Packable Light Down-Filled Puffer Coat [10.4%] Size up if in between! 


Premium Denim

  1. AG The Legging Raw Hem Ankle Skinny Jeans [37.9%] Size up if in between! 
  2. Paige Hoxton High Waist Skinny Jeans [23.9%] True to size! 
  3. Rag & Bone High Waist Ankle Skinny Jeans [14.7%] Size up if in between! 

Denim, under $100

  1. Wit & Wisdom Ab-solution Ankle Skimmer Jeans [25.6%] Size down! 
  2. Abercrombie and Fitch High-Rise Super Skinny Jeans [12.2%] True to size! 
  3. Lucky Brand Brooke Jeggings [11.2%] True to size! 

Denim, under $60

  1. American Eagle Jeggings [55.1%] Size up if in between! 
  2. Jessica Simpson Kiss Me Skinny Jeans [14%] True to size! 
  3. Mossimo High Rise Raw Hem Jeans [6.9%] True to size! 

Black Jeans

  1. Wit & Wisdom Ab-Solution Stretch Ankle Skinny Jeans [27.6%] Size down! 
  2. Kut From The Kloth Donna Ponte Knit Skinny Jeans [25.9%] Size down if in between! 
  3. Paige Transcend Hoxton High Waist Undone Hem Skinny Jeans [17.7%] True to size! 

White Jeans

  1. American Eagle Denim x Jegging Crop [28%] Size up if in between! 
  2. Kut From The Kloth Crop Skinny Jeans [28%] True to size! 
  3. Paige Verdugo Crop [16.9%] True to size! 


  1. Old Navy Boyfriend Cutoffs [28.6%] True to size! 
  2. Kut from Kloth Gidget Denim Shorts [20.4%] Size down! 
  3. BlankNYC Demin Cutoff Shorts [16.4%] True to size! 


  1. Zella Live In High Waist Leggings [43.3%] True to size! 
  2. Spanx Faux Leather Leggings [10.4%] Size up! 
  3. Old Navy High Rise Compression Leggings [9.6%] True to size! 

Casual Pants

  1. American Eagle Super Hi-Rise Jegging [32.2%] True to size! 
  2. BP Moto Leggings [22%] True to size! 
  3. Wit & Wisdom Ab-Solution Stretch Twill Skinny Pants [21.7%] Size down! 

Lounge Pants

  1. Barefoot Dreams Lounge Pants [30.2%] True to size! 
  2. Make +Model Best Boyfriend Brushed Hacci Lounge Pants [19.4%] True to size! 
  3. Make + Model Good Vibes Jogger Pants [13.7%] True to size! 

Work Wear

Dress Pants

  1. Express Columnist Pants [40.9%] True to size! 
  2. Spanx Faux Leather Leggings [27.4%] Size up! 
  3. Boden Hampshire ⅞ Pants [7.1%] Size up! 

Work Top

  1. Lush Perfect Roll Tab Sleeve Tunic [36%] Size down! 
  2. Old Navy Lightweight Tunic [13.7%] True to size! 
  3. Express Portofino Shirt [10.6%] True to size! 

Work Dress

  1. Halogen Ponte Fit and Flare Dress [29.3%] True to size! 
  2. Old Navy Ponte Knit Sheath Dress [22.9%] True to size! 
  3. Old Navy Textured Double Knit Sheath Dress [19.4%] True to size! 


  1. Olivia Moon Knit Blazer [23.6%] Size down if in between! 
  2. Caslon Knit Open Front Blazer [20.6%] True to size! 
  3. Olivia Moon Knit Tie Sleeve Blazer [16.1%] Size down if in between! 

Work Heels

  1. Sam Edelmen Hazel Pumps [26.3%] True to size! 
  2. Nine West Shatala Half D’Orsay Pumps [25.7%] True to size! 
  3. Sam Edelman Yaro Heels [19.7%] True to size! 

Bags & Shoes


  1. BP. Tonal Stripe Foldover Clutch [29.6%]
  2. Rebecca Minkoff Envelope Clutch [26%]
  3. Stella & Dot City Slim Clutch [16%]


  1. Vince Camuto Kirie Suede Crossbody [30%]
  2. BP. Foldover Crossbody Bag [21.6%]
  3. Sole Society Mikayla Satchel [13%]


  1. Sole Society Rome Vegan Leather Tote [19%]
  2. Chloe Medium Marcie Leather Satchel [16%]
  3. Sole Society Susan Winged Faux Leather Tote [12%]


  1. Sam Edelman Greta Sandal [38%] Size up .5!
  2. Sam Edelman Gigi [32%] Size up .5!
  3. American Rag Krista T-Strap Sandal [5%] True to size! 


  1. Sam Edelman Hazel Pumps [29%] Size up! 
  2. Sam Edelman Yaro [28%] True to size! 
  3. Sam Edelman Addison Ankle Strap Sandal [17%] True to size! 


  1. Converse Shoreline [46%] True to size! 
  2. Steve Madden Ecentrcq [12%] Size up one full size! 
  3. Converse Jack Purcell Low Top Sneakers [6%] True to size! 

Athletic Shoes

  1. Nike Free RN Flyknit [35.4%] True to size! 
  2. Nike Free Run Distance 2 [35.2%] Size up .5!
  3. Nike Air VaporMax Flyknit [3%] True to size! 

Open Toe Booties

  1. Vince Camuto Kensa Peep Toe Booties [43%] Size down .5! 
  2. Vince Camuto Karinta Block Heel Booties [22%] True to size! 
  3. Toms Majorca Peep Toe Booties [17%] True to size! 

Closed Toe Booties

  1. Lucky Brielley Bootie [25%] True to size! 
  2. Lucky Brand Basel Bootie [15%] True to size! 
  3. Vince Camuto Prasata Bootie [11%] Size down .5! 

Riding Boots

  1. Born Felicia Knee High Boots [25%] True to size! 
  2. Sam Edelman ‘Penny’ Boot [20%] True to size! 
  3. Born Poly Riding Boots [16%] True to size! 

Wet Weather Boots

  1. Hunter Tall Gloss Boots [26%] Size down for 1/2 sizes! 
  2. Hunter Tall Boot [23%] Size down for 1/2 sizes! 
  3. Sorel Joan of Arctic Wedge Mid Bootie [9%] True to size! 


  1. Ugg Dakota Slippers [23%] Size up one size! 
  2. Ugg Wrin Rib-Knit Slipper [19.4%] Size up one size! 
  3. Ugg Ansley Slippers [19.4%] Size up one size! 

Undergarments and Accessories


  1. Victoria’s Secret Body by Victoria [34%]
  2. Third Love 24/7 Bra [15%]
  3. Natori Feathers Underwire Contour Bra [12%]
  4. Strapless Bra – Wacaol Red Carpet Convertible Strapless Bra


  1. Barefoot Dreams CozyChic Socks [26%]
  2. Nordstrom Butter Socks [19%]
  3. American Eagle Marled Crew Socks [11%]

No Show Socks

  1. Nike No Show Socks [60.5%]
  2. Peds No Show Liner Socks [13%]
  3. Converse All Star No Show Socks [6%]

Brand of Swimwear

  1. Athleta [53%]
  2. Aerie [8%]
  3. Maaji [6%]

Swim Coverup

  1. La Blanca Cover-Up Tunic [29%]
  2. Old Navy Linen Blend Swim Romper [24.4%]
  3. Elan Cover-Up Slipdress [14.7%]


  1. BP. Heritage Plaid Infinity Scarf [52%]
  2. BP. Marled Plaid Scarf [12.3%]
  3. BP. Plaid Oblong Scarf [8.4%]


  1. BP. Knit Beanie with Faux Fur Pom Pom [40.8%]
  2. AE Pom Beanie [19.4%]
  3. Abercrombie & Fitch Pom Pom Hat [13.5%]


  1. Kendra Scott Drop Earrings [27%]
  2. Nickel & Suede Leather Earrings, various colors [17%]
  3. Stella & Dot Charlotte Druzy Earrings [8.6%]


  1. BP. Bar Pendant Necklace [37.9%]
  2. Stella & Dot Fringe Necklace [9.1%]
  3. BP. Stone Fringe Pendant Necklace [9.1%]

And that concludes ALL of YOUR top picks! What surprised you? Did your favorites make the list? Which are you MOST excited to try? 2018 – you’ve never looked better 😉

share this with your best girlfriends:

Read More

All of my favorite at-home hair care and styling products!

Read More

Sweatshirt [true to size] // Shorts [size up, wearing in medium] // Sneakers [true to size] The results are in, and these Amazon shorts are a WIN! We tried ’em from size XS to Large [in all the colors of the rainbow], and over and over we’re giving ’em nothing but raving reviews! Take a […]

Read More

My favorite beauty must-haves, all in one spot!

Read More

From tasty snacks to easy, ready-to-make meals, we’re sharing our favorite Delicious and Healthy Foods from Trader Joe’s.

Oldies but Goodies

Check Out These

The newsletter you actually want to read.

signed, sealed, delivered.

© Living in Yellow. Site Credits.